Why People Avoid ppm

Image Credit: Bart Everson (CC BY 2.0)

The job of expressing quantities between 0 and 1 usually falls to the percent (%) sign.  And when it’s used in this context, the % sign takes on the same value as 0.01.

The parts per million (ppm) convention works similarly to express quantities far smaller than 1 %.  In this context, 1 ppm equals 1 x 10-6 (i.e. one divided by 1 million).  The notion extends to parts per billion (ppb) and parts per trillion (ppt) wherever even smaller quantities are necessary. 

External Links: Links to external web pages have been provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only. Unboxing Tomorrow and Voxidyne Media bear no responsibility for the accuracy, legality or content of the external site or for that of subsequent links. Contact the external site for answers to questions regarding its content.

The dimensionless parts-per-quantity approach can express extremely small numbers without resorting to awkwardly large numbers of zeros right of the decimal point (or exponents, for that matter).

Resistors for example have a resistance (R) that will vary with a change in temperature (T-Tref), but only slightly.  Consequentially the temperature coefficient of a resistor (αppm) may be small enough to approximate using ppm/°C…

R\ \cong\ R_{ref}\left(1+\alpha_{ppm}\frac{T-T_{ref}}{{10}^6}\right)

…where Rref is the resistance at a reference temperature Tref (such as 20 °C).

There are 2 reasons why this blog avoids the parts-per-quantity convention whenever possible.

Reason #1: For Clarity

From a technical writing standpoint, relatively little insight can be gained from the ppm notation compared to other expressions.  An alternate way to specify the above resistor’s temperature coefficient or any other parts-per-quantity form would be to include the unit of measure as part of the statement.

For example, a resistor with a temperature coefficient of 1 ppm/°C could also be expressed as:

1 (Ω/106 Ω)/°C

Multiplying the inside of the parenthesis by 10-6/10-6 will get the exponential term out of the denominator…

10-6 (Ω/Ω)/°C

Finally, the micro (µ) metric prefix can replace the number 10-6

1 (µΩ/Ω)/°C

The presence of µΩ/Ω immediately signals that the expression relates to electrical resistance rather than the many other units ppm could possibly refer to.

Likewise, the idea may be extended to ppb and ppt…

1 ppm –> 1 (µΩ/Ω)

1 ppb –> 1 (nΩ/Ω)

1 ppt –> 1 (pΩ/Ω)

Reason #2: Language Independence

There is also a language conflict between the words “billion,” “trillion” and the quantities they are meant to express.  This is because “billion” can mean either 109 or 1012, depending on whether the publication uses the short scale decimal system or the long scale system.

Table 1: Short Decimal Scale Versus Long Decimal Scale

QUANTITYSCI NOTATIONSHORT SCALE LONG SCALE
1100oneone
1 000103thousandthousand
1 000 000106millionmillion
1 000 000 000109billion(milliard)
1 000 000 000 0001012trillionbillion
1 000 000 000 000 0001015quadrillion(billiard)
1 000 000 000 000 000 0001018quintilliontrillion

In North America (where Unboxing Tomorrow is based), the short scale system is almost a given.  Other countries, historic documents, or publications from the United Kingdom prior to the 1970’s are a different matter.  This trouble is compounded by the naming conflict between parts-per-thousand (ppt) and parts-per-thousand (also ppt).

Unless the context is completely unambiguous, this blog will normally follow the National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST) recommended unit/unit notation. 

References

[1]U.S. NIST, “Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI),” U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2008. [Online]. Available: https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/Legacy/SP/nistspecialpublication811e2008.pdf. [Accessed 30 Sept. 2022].

Thumbnail Image Credit: Bart Everson (CC BY 2.0)

Important Notice: This article and its contents (the “Information”) belong to Unboxing-tomorrow.com and Voxidyne Media LLC. No license is granted for the use of it other than for information purposes. No license of any intellectual property rights is granted.  The Information is subject to change without notice. The Information supplied is believed to be accurate, but Voxidyne Media LLC assumes no responsibility for its accuracy or completeness, any error in or omission from it or for any use made of it.  Liability for loss or damage resulting from any reliance on the Information or use of it (including liability resulting from negligence or where Voxidyne Media LLC was aware of the possibility of such loss or damage arising) is excluded.