Components Survival Guide: LEDs Part 2

Light emitting diodes
Green, blue, and magenta light emitting diodes

White light emitting diodes (LEDs) can be fabricated from blue LEDs with a yellow-emitting phosphor or substrate.  These combined blue-yellow emissions fool the human eye into perceiving white light.  This project will focus on white LEDs and their photometrics: luminous flux, luminous intensity, luminous efficacy, and illuminance.

Notice of Non-Affiliation and Disclaimer: As of the publication date, we are not affiliated with, associated with, authorized with, endorsed by, compensated by, or in any way officially connected with Lumileds, or their owners, subsidiaries or affiliates. The names Lumileds, LUXEON, as well as related names, marks, emblems, and images are trademarks of their respective owners.

External Links: Links to external web pages have been provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only. Unboxing Tomorrow and Voxidyne Media bear no responsibility for the accuracy, legality or content of the external site or for that of subsequent links. Contact the external site for answers to questions regarding its content.

Electrostatics Notice

Users who mishandle LEDs can damage them through electrostatic discharge (ESD).  ESD-damaged LEDs will exhibit abnormalities such as failure to light at low currents, low forward voltage, and high reverse leakage current.  Anyone handling LEDs should wear a grounded anti-static wrist band or use similar anti-static countermeasures.

White LED Photometrics

Components Survival Guide: LEDs Part 1 covered color LEDs that emit only a narrow part of the visible spectrum.  Effectively, LEDS are current-dependent light sources.  White LEDs are no exception, but their wider distribution of colors makes certain metrics such as peak wavelength and dominant wavelength ineffective.

The human eye is well-adapted to sunlight (at sea level).  Consequentially, mid-day sunlight is a common reference for “neutral” white light.

But an artificial light source may visibly favor one color or another…

  • Warm white LEDs skewed toward yellow emissions
  • Cool white LEDs skewed toward blue emissions

Fortunately, physicists created the idea of a color space or color gamut wherenumeric values align with different color combinations.  As of the early 21st century, the Commission Internationale de l’éclairage (CIE) color spaces are the most relevant since they map these 3 color values to a 2-dimensional multi-colored chart.  Thanks to the CIE 1931 diagram (shown in Figure 1), visible colors map to x y coordinates…

Figure 1: CIE chromaticity diagram including the Planckian Locus

Correlated Color Temperature

Near the center of the CIE chart is an arc that approximates the white light of incandescent sources.   This arc (the Planckian Locus) is marked with temperature graduations measured in degrees Kelvin (°K).

LED manufactures use the Correlated Color Temperature (CCT) scale to express where their white LED emissions fit along the Planckian Locus.

Table 1: Light Sources and their typical correlated color temperature

LIGHT SOURCECORRELATED COLOR TEMPERATURE (°K)
Candlelight1,500
Sunrise/sunset3,200
1 h before/after dusk/dusk3,400
LED Luxeon White, 5 W5,500
Sunny daylight around noon5,800
Fluorescent lamp2,700-8,000

Two important notes…

  1. The CCT scale is a visual metaphor and does not express the actual temperature of an LED.  Generally, LED junctions operate below 425 °K.
  2. Because terms warm white and cool white are rooted in human intuition and instinct, the CCT scale ironically contradicts it by associating cooler white with higher temperatures.
Figure 2: Three light sources of varying correlated color temperature

Color Rendering Index

Color Rendering Index (CRI) is another metric associated with white LEDs.  Effectively, CRI answers the question: “compared to the sun, how accurate do colors look under this light source?”  In other words, CRI expresses color fidelity.

Figure 3: A red car (parked left) and a black car (parked right) may appear the same color under the low-CRI, low-pressure sodium lamps. (License: CC-BY-SA-4.0)

The CRI scale ranges from 0 to 100.  A CRI of 100 approximates mid-day sunlight.  To an average adult, sources with CRI lower than 60 will appear tinted a particular color.

Table 2: Some light sources and their typical color rendering index (CRI)

LIGHT SOURCECOLOR RENDERING INDEX
Low-pressure sodium lamp0-18
High-pressure sodium lamp25-82
High-pressure mercury lamp16-58
Warm White Fluorescent lamp55
Cool white fluorescent lamp65
LED Luxeon white 5 W70
Deluxe warm white fluorescent lamp73
Daylight fluorescent lamp79
Metal halide lamp (4,200 K)85
Deluxe cool white fluorescent lamp86
Incandescent lamp (100 W)100

Low CRI is not necessarily bad.  For example: low-pressure sodium lamps have high energy efficiency, yet low CRI.  Together CRI and CCT are important factors in choosing a light source in locations were color rendering matters (example: textiles, hotels, galleries).

Luminous Flux (lumens)

Luminous flux (unit of measure: lumens, abbreviated: lm) rating describes the total light energy a light source emits per unit time (dQ/dt).  This rating is weighted to the sensitivity of human vision and only accounts for visible light emissions.

In the 20th century, consumer-grade incandescent bulbs used wattage to express bulb brightness.  In practice, this was acceptable only for informally comparing one incandescent product to another.  But the lumen rating is more reliable since it describes the light leaving the source rather than the power entering.

Luminous Intensity (W sr-1)

Luminous intensity expresses the brightness of the LED beam in a general direction.  The unit of measure: watts per steradian (W sr-1) expresses light power (watts) and divides it by a solid angle (steradians). 

Figure 4: Depiction of 1 steradian (as solid angle Ω) (License: CC BY-SA 3.0)

On the other hand, luminous flux expresses the total amount of light exiting the LED in any direction.  Because of this, 2 light sources may have the same lumen rating, yet one may cast a brighter spot than the other (example: a spotlight versus a floodlight).

Luminous Efficacy (unit: lm W-1)

The luminous flux divided by the amount of power used gives the luminous efficacy of the LED (unit: η or lm W-1).  This rating can help judge the efficiency of different lamps. 

Illuminance (Illumination)

Illuminance (unit: 1 lux = l lm m-2) expresses the brightness of an illuminated surface positioned some distance away from the LED.  This photometric is useful in expressing how bright a surface will appear under the light source.

Table 3: Some typical light sources and their Illuminances

SCENEILLUMINANCE (lux)
Clear night under a full moon at zenth0.1 to 0.2
Street lighting3 to 30
Domestic lighting40 to 150
Bright officeUp to 400
Winter day (cloudy)3,000 to 4,000
Summer day (clear)32,000 to 100,000

LED Disadvantages

LEDs have disadvantages related to heat and heat dissipation.

As forward current increases, an LED will grow warm under its own joule heating (albeit not nearly as much as an incandescent bulb).  If the LED junction grows hot enough, it will reach a point where an increase in current causes a decrease in luminous flux.  Effectively: the work-around is to either use aggressive heatsinking or simply add more LEDs.  This is why LED assemblies often contain arrays of LEDs rather than a single giant LED.

LED application circuits and drive methods will be covered in the 3rd and final part: “Components Survival Guide: LEDs Part 3.”

References

[1]P. Flesch, “Light and Light Sources,” in Light and Light Sources – High Intensity Discharge Lamps, Berlin, Springer, 2006, pp. 1-50.
[2]D. Tree, Artist, Red and black cars under low pressure sodium lamps.jpg. [Art]. Wikimedia Commons, 2013.
[3]R. Hui, “Unifying PET theory with colorimetry,” in Photo-Electro-Thermal Theory for LED Systems, Basic Theory and Applications, Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, 2017, pp. 61-63.
[4]Haade, Artist, Solid Angle.png. [Art]. Wikimedia Commons, 2007.

Important Notice: This article and its contents (the “Information”) belong to Unboxing-tomorrow.com and Voxidyne Media LLC. No license is granted for the use of it other than for information purposes. No license of any intellectual property rights is granted.  The Information is subject to change without notice. The Information supplied is believed to be accurate, but Voxidyne Media LLC assumes no responsibility for its accuracy or completeness, any error in or omission from it or for any use made of it.  Liability for loss or damage resulting from any reliance on the Information or use of it (including liability resulting from negligence or where Voxidyne Media LLC was aware of the possibility of such loss or damage arising) is excluded.